How to Know If Your Roof Needs Replaced or Just Repaired

When your roof starts showing signs of wear, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. Should you patch the problem or start fresh with a full replacement? At Cambria Exteriors, we get this question all the time — and the truth is, it depends on a few key factors.

Here’s how to tell whether a repair will do the job, or if it’s time to consider a full roof replacement.

Signs You May Only Need a Repair

If your roof is generally in good shape, you might be able to get by with a professional repair. Look for:

Minor Leaks

A small water spot in your attic or ceiling may be caused by a loose shingle or flashing issue — not full roof failure.

Isolated Damage

Wind or hail may damage a single section of shingles, especially on older asphalt roofs. If the rest of the roof is intact, a localized fix can restore it.

Recent Installation

If your roof is less than 10–12 years old and well-maintained, a repair is typically more cost-effective than full replacement.

Signs It’s Time for a Full Roof Replacement

Some problems go beyond patching — and delaying replacement can lead to bigger issues like mold, structural damage, and rising energy bills.

Widespread Shingle Damage

Are your shingles curling, cracking, or missing across large sections of your roof? That’s a sign the materials are reaching the end of their lifespan.

Frequent Leaks

If you’re calling for repairs often, those patch jobs may be masking a bigger problem underneath.

If leaks are storm-related, you may qualify for insurance coverage. The Pennsylvania Insurance Department outlines what homeowners should know about filing a claim for roof repairs or replacement.

Sagging or Soft Spots

A sagging roofline or spongy spots could mean rot or damage to the underlying structure — which repairs alone can’t fix.

Your Roof is 20+ Years Old

Roofs don’t last forever. If yours is two decades old or more, it may be safer and more economical to replace it before major issues arise.

Older roofs can also contribute to energy loss, especially when paired with outdated insulation. Get guidance on how roof upgrades improve energy efficiency and reduce long-term utility costs.

Repair vs. Replace: What’s Best for You?

Every roof is different — and the best way to know for sure is to schedule a professional inspection. At Cambria Exteriors, we’ll assess the damage, explain your options clearly, and never upsell you on something you don’t need.

Ready to Get Started?

Whether it’s a quick fix or a full upgrade, we’re here to help. Contact Cambria Exteriors today for a free inspection and honest advice on what your roof really needs.

Request a Free Quote